36 Comments
founding

The CBC has decided it is the conscience of Canada. A Toronto-centric, woke, identity politics centred conscience. Run by a woman who lives in NYC. In theory we need an independent Canadian media alternative. In practise whenever I stumble on to the CBC, I turn it off.

Expand full comment

On school closures: BC's consistently kept the schools open. Omicron is spreading so rapidly that students may well be just as likely to get it outside school as inside school.

With widespread vaccination, the personal risk from Omicron doesn't seem as high. I'm hearing about people getting Omicron through my social network, and so far all the cases appear to be mild, fortunately. The big issues are (a) the huge strain on the health-care system from the sheer number of cases, and (b) Omicron is contagious enough that it's finding the pockets of unvaccinated people who haven't been touched so far.

Expand full comment
Jan 8, 2022·edited Jan 8, 2022

There's a general misconception that it's only wealthy families who are bailing on the school system. This simply isn't true as research has demonstrated already that families are leaving the system because it has failed their children, regardless of their SES status ((https://www.cardus.ca/research/education/reports/who-chooses-ontario-independent-schools-and-why/). Quite simply, parents will sacrifice, and do whatever it takes for their kids to have an opportunity in a pre or post COVID world irrespective of their income level, and that's exactly what they're doing. COVID has peeled back the dysfunction of our public system but for many of us it's merely an eye roll about what we've been pointing out for years. As the editors of The Line have young kids, perhaps it might warrant a story as to what the truth is behind why enrolment levels of homeschooling and independent schools are increasing exponentially, while public school enrolment remains relatively flat...all the while education funding levels continue to increase unabated. As for the Omicron response by our political leaders, they are clearly demonstrating they have absolutely no clue what to do. We need to get on with our lives and learn to live with COVID, rather than pretend these draconian lockdowns are doing anything but continue to stoke fear and resentment amongst the general public. Perhaps this health official has said it best: "The risk to most [vaccinated] individuals right now of Omicron is very low. The risk that Omicron is causing society in terms of widespread dysfunction is very high." https://www.economist.com/united-states/in-america-the-pandemic-has-seemingly-hit-a-turning-point/21807003?utm_campaign=coronavirus-special-edition&utm_medium=newsletter&utm_source=salesforce-marketing-cloud&utm_term=2022-01-08&utm_content=article-link-4&etear=nl_special_4. No wonder confidence in our government leaders is at an all time low. Who can blame us?

Expand full comment

"Shutting schools to save the elderly and unvaccinated when vaccines are widely available amounts to nothing short of an intergenerational crime at this point."

Maybe you might think about dialling back the ageism, Jen. It's getting tiresome and distracts from your commentary on real issues.

Expand full comment

I don't think Ford ever intended to close the schools but forced with a teacher refusal to return (they say it's due to staff shortages, but given the Brooklyn work-around response to NYC mayor's decree that schools will open, I suspect the teachers in general flexed their power and said NO) he needed to save face, so he declared it himself.

He -smartly in a tactical sense- also shutdown businesses to cut off the refrain of "schools should be the last to close and the first to open" but, more importantly, plans to have businesses still closed when the schools are set to re-open. This means all focus will be on the schools/teachers when that day comes.

So the teachers will be forced to return or feel the wrath of the parents. for years to come.

Expand full comment

"It’s traditionally been the right that has hated the CBC in this country, for reasons good and bad. The left, in contrast, has cherished it, or at least valued it. Does it still? We ask this question very sincerely. ... Is the CBC as it exists today something anyone would get fired up to defend?"

It's a good question, non-polemically put. My mother was a panelist on CBC's Front Page Challenge for years, and I've done contract work for CBC myself and enjoyed and respected the people I met there. As I've also consistently voted either NDP or Green, you might infer that I'm likely quite favourably disposed toward CBC. Yet I'm also a retired reference librarian who takes information access issues seriously. It's hard for our judgment to be more reliable than the information that informs it, and in all honesty I can no longer recommend the CBC as a reliable information source. CBC's leadership has clearly lost sight of the important difference between reporting on the culture wars and trying to win them for one side: the former is a legitimate journalistic responsibility while the latter is a task for social engineers. The merits and demerits of the social engineering impulse may be matters of controversy, but surely the unacceptability of social engineers masquerading themselves as journalists shouldn't be.

CBC isn't alone amongst institutional media entities in having taken this transparently ideological path, of course, but to the extent that the corporation's mandate entails a responsibility to reflect the concerns of as broad a range of Canadians as possible its strategic direction is puzzling and its failures of vision particularly disappointing. Like most Canadians I'm a moderate, and while I vote left I'm no more anxious to consume propaganda that pretends to speak on my behalf than its counterpart from the other end of the political spectrum. The antidote to propaganda isn't counter-propaganda but anti-propaganda, and whoever CBC thinks it's catering to with its drumbeat, one-note messaging, it isn't me. Encountering anyone else who feels CBC articulates their concerns is an increasing rarity, which gives CBC broadcasts suffused with the supposition that this is exactly what the programming is doing a sad air of unreality.

Expand full comment

Regarding CDN politics (ignore my comment below about not following) I've wondered for a while why Canada has gone so woke. My thinking is that with Quebec out of the running it has shifted the power from there to the cities (specifically Vancouver and Toronto 416) and the. Cities tend to be very left and very woke. Now O'tooles Liberal Lite platform makes sense. Hmmm I might even vote in the next election (was seriously considering not)

Expand full comment

Good morning and greetings from Germany where, after a rough start, the vaccination rollout is going great guns! Sooo how's things going here. Well I noticed this in the German media (link below) "Omicron spike in most vaccinated German state heralds nationwide surge". How much,

"The seven-day infection rate in Bremen stood at 800 cases per 100,000 residents on Thursday, the highest in Germany and more than double the national rate of 303, according to the Robert Koch Institute (RKI) for infectious diseases."

And what is the response to this? Do you need to even ask? Mmore restrictions and talk of a 4th booster and of course next winter, more of the same. As I said at the very beginning, the pandemic will end long before the restrictions do!

Oh and while I've mostly (completely) stopped following CDN news I still subscribe to the line for, as Jen said, "an outlet for engaging, irreverent writing" and Matt and Jen excel at this!

Keep up the good work guys

Rob Abroad!

Expand full comment
Jan 9, 2022·edited Jan 10, 2022

The predictably uniform, institutional media consensus is that Omicron is a danger whose spread must be stopped, or at least retarded as much as possible, by any means necessary. Apparently, no pundit, medical expert or other potential interview subject can be found who thinks otherwise. Meantime, if there can be said to be an internet consensus it coalesces around the idea that Omicron is a blessing in disguise. A COVID variant that spreads like wildfire while causing real harm to almost no one promises herd immunity more robust and widespread than vaccines can possibly deliver, and without vaccines' downside risks. Could there be a starker illustration of the bifurcated information world we now live in? The extent to which institutional media still contrives to pretend the realm of the internet doesn't exist is astonishing in 2022, and the gulf between 'official' narratives and what people have confidence is true is equally so.

It's a rupture with important consequences for decision-making. Is vaccinating children against Omicron's supposedly deleterious effects the responsible thing to do, as institutional media insists? Or is using mRNA technology to send spike proteins coursing through young bodies an act of lunacy that not only addresses no real threat of harm but prevents children from developing lasting immunity to future threats, as dissident internet voices suggest? Ideally, we would want our experts to be on the same page with such questions; but is emphasizing or suppressing narratives according to criteria that seem transparently political and ideological, instead of guided by the demands of truth pursuit, a reliable road to meaningful consensus? How can we trust data sources that exhibit more concern for satisfying criteria of the former sort than the latter?

NB:

The path not taken that possibly (indeed probably) should have been:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-zg1j7Zquoc

Informed consent on Omicron, and the ethics of making decisions on others' behalf:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dEcu04Setns

Expand full comment

Perhaps the CBC could be saved but what price salvation? When that percent of an entity has gone gangrenous it is not the practical solution. The cost involved to show only one colour on your television would never be acceptable and the remedy seems obvious. The infestation at the Ceeb seems to have reached the point of no return when even the mildly woke are abandoning ship. It’s time.

Expand full comment

I, and 100% of my friends and family I have surveyed, consider the rapid tests being sent home next week as a kind of Education Shit Test. How badly do you want your kids' in class education to commence?

I will look at my double Pfizer'ed perfectly healthy 14 year old who wants to be a pilot and I will shove the two boxes of tests in the junk drawer. Where they will be found 3 years from now when I'm searching for a AAA. Ok, maybe I'll open one box to check if you can, in fact, produce a false positive by dipping it in beer.

Expand full comment
Removed (Banned)Jan 8, 2022
Comment removed
Expand full comment